Black Athena Writes Back: Martin Bernal Responds to His CriticsIn Black Athena Writes Back Martin Bernal responds to the passionate debates set off by the 1987 publication of his book Black Athena. Producing a shock wave of reaction from scholars, Black Athena argued that the development of Greek civilization was heavily influenced by Afroasiatic civilizations. Moreover, Bernal asserted that this knowledge had been deliberately obscured by the rampant racism of nineteenth-century Europeans who could not abide the notion that Greek society—for centuries recognized as the originating culture of Europe—had its origins in Africa and Southwest Asia. The subsequent rancor among classicists over Bernal’s theory and accusations was picked up in the popular media, and his suggestion that Greek culture had its origin in Africa was widely derided. In a report on 60 Minutes, for example, it was suggested that Bernal’s hypothesis was essentially an attempt to provide blacks with self-esteem so that they would feel included in the march of progress. In Black Athena Writes Back Bernal provides additional documentation to back up his thesis, as well as offering persuasive explanations of why traditional scholarship on the subject remains inaccurate and why specific arguments lobbed against his theories are themselves faulty. Black Athena Writes Back requires no prior familiarity with either the Black Athena hypothesis or with the arguments advanced against it. It will be essential reading for those who have been following this long-running debate, as well as for those just discovering this fascinating subject. |
From inside the book
Results 1-5 of 83
Page 1
... scholars from a number of disciplines . These writers , while conceding various merits to my work , are generally ... scholarly reasons , others from a mixture of scholarly and what I perceive to be right - wing political motives . The ...
... scholars from a number of disciplines . These writers , while conceding various merits to my work , are generally ... scholarly reasons , others from a mixture of scholarly and what I perceive to be right - wing political motives . The ...
Page 4
... scholars begin to deny the ancient colonizations and play down Egyptian and Phoenician cultural influences on Greece . These historiographical developments cannot be linked to the availability of any new evidence . The great discoveries ...
... scholars begin to deny the ancient colonizations and play down Egyptian and Phoenician cultural influences on Greece . These historiographical developments cannot be linked to the availability of any new evidence . The great discoveries ...
Page 7
... scholars seems to have been the new axiom that Europe was , and had always been , categorically separate from and su- perior to Asia and Africa . Thus , proof was required to justify something as unnatural as the Ancient model.9 The ...
... scholars seems to have been the new axiom that Europe was , and had always been , categorically separate from and su- perior to Asia and Africa . Thus , proof was required to justify something as unnatural as the Ancient model.9 The ...
Page 13
... scholars who knew all three of the relevant languages : Ancient Egyptian , West Semitic , and Greek.15 Instead ... scholarly vol- ume devoted to the works of a living author not containing her or his re- sponse if she or he wished to ...
... scholars who knew all three of the relevant languages : Ancient Egyptian , West Semitic , and Greek.15 Instead ... scholarly vol- ume devoted to the works of a living author not containing her or his re- sponse if she or he wished to ...
Page 14
... scholar of broad culture . Third , it implies that scholars on the periphery of a discipline ( Hopkins was professor of Greek at Dublin ) , however re- spected they are in other fields , should not tell 14 Black Athena Writes Back.
... scholar of broad culture . Third , it implies that scholars on the periphery of a discipline ( Hopkins was professor of Greek at Dublin ) , however re- spected they are in other fields , should not tell 14 Black Athena Writes Back.
Contents
Egyptology | 25 |
A Reply to David OConnor | 44 |
Classics | 53 |
A Reply to Emily Vermeule | 76 |
A Reply to Edith Hall | 90 |
Linguistics | 107 |
Historiography | 165 |
A Reply to Guy Rogers | 198 |
Recent Broadening Scholarship | 289 |
Walter Burkerts The Orientalizing Revolution Near Eastern Influence on Greek Culture in the Early Archaic Age | 308 |
A Review of Martin Wests The East Face of Helicon West Asiatic Elements in Greek Poetry and Myth | 318 |
15 Phoenician Politics and Egyptian Justice in Ancient Greece | 345 |
A Popular Effort | 373 |
Conclusion | 397 |
Notes | 401 |
Glossary | 459 |
Other editions - View all
Black Athena Writes Back: Martin Bernal Responds to His Critics Martin Bernal No preview available - 2001 |
Common terms and phrases
accept Aegean African Afroasiatic Afrocentric Afrocentrists Anatolia Ancient Egypt Ancient Egyptian Ancient Greece Ancient model archaeological Archaic argued argument Aryan model Astour Baines believe Bernal Black Athena Blok Burkert Canaanite century B.C.E. chapter claim Classical classicists Coptic Crete criticism cult cultural Cyrus Gordon Daidalos derived discussion Dynasty earlier early East Eastern Mediterranean Egyp Egyptian influence Egyptian mathematics Egyptologist European evidence fact Furthermore Greek civilization Grote Hellenistic Herodotus Hesiod historians Homer Hyksos idea Indo-Hittite influences on Greece instance Jasanoff and Nussbaum K. O. Müller language later Lefkowitz Levant Levantine linguistic loans maintain mathematics Mesopotamia Mill Mill's millennium B.C.E. modern Morris Müller Mycenaean myths Neogrammarians Nevertheless nineteenth Oriental origin Palter parallels period Phoenician phonetic Plato plausible political racism reason refer Review Roman scholars semantic Southwest Asia texts tian tion tradition Tritle Ugaritic Vermeule Walter Burkert West Semitic words writing wrote
Popular passages
Page 14 - For dignity composed, and high exploit: But all was false and hollow ; though his tongue Dropp'd manna, and could make the worse appear The better reason, to perplex and dash Maturest counsels...